(301) 531-4010 | Email

Bookfresh vs. Setster for Online Appointments

April 21st, 2010

Do you remember the days before cell phones? Contractors and business owners had pagers and Daytimers. I remember my dad telling me that when he worked in the field painting for a homeowner, he’d have to ask the homeowner if he could use their phone to make a call or drive to the nearest pay phone. Life was simple. Asking to use someone’s phone was not an inconvenience. It was normal. Yet, the days of pagers, pay phones, daytimers and people waiting 24+ hours for a response are over! Now consumers want quick and fast response. If they send an email, they get impatient if they don’t hear back from a contractor within 2 hours or less. Some consumers don’t even like talking on the phone. They would prefer scheduling their appointments online at their convenience.

Well, to keep up with technology and this fast pace lifestyle, Bookfresh and Setster have made it a little easier for business owners to allow prospects and customers to schedule appointments onlineBookfresh and Setster are online scheduling and appointment booking software. A visitor can now go on to a contractor’s website, click on the “Contact Us” or “Book Now” button, select a service, view available time slots and schedule an appointment. Both of these companies have made online scheduling a breeze.

Which one do I like best? It is hard to say. I like them both. Bookfresh seems to have done a better job marketing themselves and has more testimonials from places like the New York Times and USA Today. Setster, is a younger company yet is slowly becoming a threat to compete neck to neck with Bookfresh.

Pros of Bookfresh

  • Mobile friendly: browser-based website to view and accept appointments
  • Attractive and Easy to Use.
  • Available on your Business Facebook Page and Email Campaigns
  • Has a “mini site” for your company. This could replace your company contact page completely. It is easy to use and search-engine friendly
  • Integrates pretty well with Outlook and Google Calendars
Cons of Bookfresh
  • For contractors, there is no function to schedule specific areas of town. In other words, if you want to schedule appointments in the same zip code or area, there is no way to do this. Bookfresh makes scheduling easy for the consumer only.
  • Bookfresh takes a consumer away from a contractor’s website. This is not good from a marketing perspective. It should be a pop up menu with the contractors brand and identity. When a consumer clicks on the Book Now button, Bookfresh takes over.
  • Customer support, in my opinion is terrible. If you want phone support, you pay more per month: around $30. However, I’ve tried this route and still had a very difficult time getting in touch for several of my clients. This is really the downside to Bookfresh. They should offer free support for 1 month. They really cannot rely completely on email support when they are dealing with non techy people at times. This is the one reason I cannot highly recommend their product.

Pros of Setster

  • Customer Services. Each time I’ve had an issue, they’ve respond by email well…and even picked up the phone and called me to make sure I was happy.
  • Easy to view on a mobile phone and approve appointments
  • Pricing is good. It use to be cheaper than Bookfresh. Just a couple weeks ago, they raised their prices to be similar to Bookfresh. Basic plan starts at around $20 a month.
  • Branding of Setster is limited. A Consumer stays on a contractor’s website when booking an appointment.
  • Easy to install buttons for email marketing, website and sending business emails.
  • Works very well with Google Calendar.
  • Invoice and Accept Payments online (Integrates with Quickbooks, Freshbooks and PayPal)

Cons of Setster

  • Not as mobile friendly as Bookfresh and no App available yet.
  • The calendar function is not as design-friendly as Bookfresh
  • Does not accept Credit Card payments from Authorize.net. The account owner has to use PayPal. I would think it would be easy to add a Merchant Service account other than PayPal.

Bookfresh and Setster are great programs! Consumers use these features and seem to like the ease of them. If Bookfresh would have better customer service, I’d give them two thumbs up. Until then, Setster takes the cake.

  1. April 21st, 2010 at 07:04 | #1

    For those reading that would like a booking solution that can support a multitude of business types and allows for a more seamless integration into other sites, you might want to check out http://www.bookingbug.com!

  2. Matt
    June 10th, 2010 at 10:58 | #2

    Amen on Bookfresh’s lousy customer support. Thanks for the write up. The thing that’s stopped me from using Setster is that double confirmation with emails (clients have to confirm their email address before the appointment does get made), but has that been an issue at all for you?

  3. Matt
    June 10th, 2010 at 10:59 | #3

    Also, Bookfresh’s google calendar integration seems to be a bit buggy. You say setster’s is really good — how has that been going? Still smooth integration?

  4. June 10th, 2010 at 11:36 | #4

    Here is the ultimate problem I’m seeing in the mobile and online word: there is NOT a good program that DOES IT ALL. So, Google is good and Setster is good, but the syncing is not instant. It could take 15 minutes to sync from Google Calendar to Setster visa versa or up to an hour. ISo I’m not happy with the timing of appointments getting from the two programs. I really hate all this 3rd party integration, to be quite honest. The problem is, Google won’t develop much more stuff yet. They are just opening the door with Google Apps…then they created the Google Marketplace for other 3rd party folks to integrate. Setster, Bookfresh, Zoho, Salesforce…all integrate. So there is a lag time with all of them. email if you have other questions: [email protected]

  5. Matt
    June 16th, 2010 at 19:11 | #5

    Too true. Thanks for the email convo on the different Bookfresh and Setster issues. I just had an email exchange with Bookfresh today. I asked if they could actually send receipts for the automatically billed $20/month they bill. They said they don’t do receipts. No “thanks for the suggestion” or “we’ll look into providing a very basic service that any business should be expected to be able to provide.” Just “we don’t do that.” Can’t wait ’til a competitor steps up their game just ever so slightly.

  6. Anne
    July 9th, 2011 at 05:59 | #6

    Might you have looked into appointmentquest? I know solo docs are using that.

    In my quick look at it and BookFresh, I like the appearance of BookFresh.

    I have never heard of docs on the forum I visit mention Bookfresh.

    Do any appointment systems do phone call reminders?

    thanks ~

  7. July 11th, 2011 at 19:28 | #7

    Thanks for stopping by. I wrote this blog before being introduced to YouCanBook.me. Have you tried them out? I love them. I wrote a blog about them too. I don’t know of any that can do a follow up call though. It can send a Text message reminder. Tell me more about the one you listed? Not familiar with it.

  8. alex
    August 26th, 2011 at 13:39 | #8

    I signed up for the $20/mo BookFresh account and found out most of BookFresh seems to be BS. The online payments engine doesn’t even work when you try to add it, it is listed as ‘unavailable’. The feature to call and text confirmations to your customers doesn’t actually work. It says it does. But it doesn’t. The one big issue is resource allocation; BookFresh forces the customer to decide ‘who’ they’d like to see… So, instead of you getting a booking and assigning a resource, BookFresh has the customer decide who they’d like to see. This might work for a salon or a nail place but it won’t work for a company selling tickets to an event or contracting services like therapy or security… Basically, it’s a worthless dog IMHO. I’m going to cancel my subscription today. Done with it. Also, AMEN to the earlier comment. Their Customer Service doesn’t’ exist – just like some of their features.

  9. August 26th, 2011 at 21:44 | #9

    Alex, thank you for letting me know. I agree with you 100%. I am not sure what happened to them. Their customer service went down the tubes. I have several customers using it and just use it “as is.” I would highly recommend looking into http://www.YouCanBook.me if you use Google Calendar. Setster also has made a few changes and I hear it is pretty good.

  10. charlene
    May 15th, 2012 at 10:17 | #10

    I see that http://www.youcanbook.me is a UK-based company. I LOVE the customizing ability of the software, but how does it work out in the US, especially concerning customer service…?

  11. May 15th, 2012 at 18:51 | #11

    Great question. I wondered the same thing originally. That was about 2 years ago and I still recommend them. The owner, Keith Harris, is very responsive. The best customer service I’ve seen with any online booking system. By the way, I don’t get a referral fee for recommending them. I refer companies that my client’s like!

  12. Charlene
    May 15th, 2012 at 20:36 | #12

    Thanks, David! Any “cons”
    That you’ve come across since you first recommended them? There are sooo many programs out there.

  13. May 16th, 2012 at 06:23 | #13

    @Charlene

    Not really. If you need something custom, you can pay them extra to build some added features.

  1. No trackbacks yet.