Neighborhood Domination (Part 2)

Posted by Emily Howard | Fri, Mar 21, 2025

 Neighborhood Domination (Part 2)

Are you look­ing to be the go-to painter in your neigh­bor­hood? Then it’s time to imple­ment neigh­bor­hood dom­i­na­tion. In Jan­u­ary, we talked a bit about this mar­ket­ing strat­e­gy, focus­ing on offline strate­gies like direct mail, but today, we’ll dive deep­er and dis­cuss weav­ing online strate­gies into your approach so that your prospects see you every­where they go.

Tar­get Your Audience

Tar­get­ing a spe­cif­ic audi­ence is the cen­tral com­po­nent of neigh­bor­hood dom­i­na­tion. The bet­ter you are at hom­ing in on your tar­get mar­ket, the fur­ther your bud­get will go and the more effec­tive the strat­e­gy will be. 

Start with what you know. You’re like­ly col­lect­ing cus­tomer data some­where, even if it’s just in Quick­Books or a spread­sheet. Ide­al­ly, you are using a CRM to help keep your data col­lec­tion con­sis­tent and orga­nized. Many CRMs can even help you more eas­i­ly iden­ti­fy pat­terns and insights in your cus­tomer list. 

Build­ing Your List of Prospects

As we dis­cussed in Neigh­bor­hood Dom­i­na­tion Part 1, you can often use your direct mail com­pa­ny to build out the list you’ll tar­get on all plat­forms. Based on your cus­tomer list, they’ll give you impor­tant insights into your cus­tomers, the size of your mar­ket and mar­ket sat­u­ra­tion, and build a list of prospects that are most like your cur­rent cus­tomer base. This list will receive your direct mail efforts. 

This is the same list you should use for your dig­i­tal efforts. Addi­tion­al­ly, depend­ing on your bud­get, you might be able to broad­en your tar­get­ing even fur­ther by build­ing looka­like audi­ences. How­ev­er, we rec­om­mend focus­ing on tar­get­ing your orig­i­nal list as often and on as many plat­forms as pos­si­ble before expand­ing. The key the neigh­bor­hood dom­i­na­tion is fre­quent and diverse touchpoints.

How­ev­er, if you do decide that you want to tar­get a larg­er audi­ence online, test your audi­ence using A/B test­ing to ensure that the expand­ed audi­ence is worth the spend. 

  1. The A test should tar­get the same prospect list as your direct mail efforts. 

  2. The B test should tar­get the looka­like audience.

Use the same art­work for each cam­paign to ensure you are only test­ing a sin­gle vari­able at a time. Com­pare the num­bers to deter­mine how well each audi­ence is performing. 

Note: If you are low on data or the plat­form doesn’t offer the option to upload your list, use the algo­rithm that the plat­form offers, fill­ing out infor­ma­tion on your ide­al cus­tomer (zip codes, inter­ests, home val­ue, income, etc.). 

Choos­ing Your Platforms

Don’t be tempt­ed to throw all your eggs in one bas­ket. You want to choose a nice mix of plat­forms for two reasons:

  1. Dif­fer­ent cus­tomers use dif­fer­ent plat­forms. You’ll reach more of your list when you meet them where they are. 

  2. Mul­ti­ple plat­forms mean mul­ti­ple touch­points, which increas­es brand recognition. 

Google Ads/​Google Local Ser­vice Ads (GLSA)

GLSAs have been very pop­u­lar late­ly. While this option has been per­form­ing well, we still don’t rec­om­mend that you move your entire Google Ad bud­get to GLASs. Start by run­ning both, track, and then allo­cate your bud­get based on the results. 

Social

It’s easy to start paid ads on social media. What’s a lit­tle hard­er is run­ning effec­tive social cam­paigns. It’s a crowd­ed and com­pet­i­tive mar­ket­place, so be pre­pared to test and opti­mize based on your find­ings. If your list work has giv­en you any infor­ma­tion on what social plat­forms your prospects are like­ly to fre­quent, start with that plat­form. If not, allo­cate some bud­get to each and start test­ing. Your met­rics will guide you to any front runners.

OTT/CTV

Smart TVs and big data have made tar­get­ed TV adver­tis­ing eas­i­er and more eco­nom­i­cal for small busi­ness­es. You can reach your audi­ence for as low as $0.02-$0.06 per com­mer­cial per house­hold. There is a mas­sive array of chan­nels you can con­sid­er like Hulu, Com­cast, Pea­cock, etc. Luck­i­ly, DIY plat­forms like Vibe allow you to tar­get an audi­ence and run your ads on mul­ti­ple chan­nels stream­lin­ing the process. 

Right now, there are few­er options for OTT/CTV to upload lists and tar­get them direct­ly. How­ev­er, you can build out an audi­ence on the plat­forms with demo­graph­ic infor­ma­tion and user habits. Want to learn more about OTT/CTV? Check out this arti­cle.

Need Help Opti­miz­ing Your Marketing?

Feel­ing over­whelmed? At A David Cre­ation, we spe­cial­ize in mar­ket­ing for painters. Our vast expe­ri­ence and insights can stream­line your mar­ket­ing process­es and get you to neigh­bor­hood dom­i­na­tion faster. Sched­ule Your Free Con­sul­ta­tion Call today!


About Emily Howard

Emily has always been passionate about the trades and joins us after 15 years as editor-in-chief at American Painting Contractor. Last year, she traded her full-time desk job to explore a career in farming. Today, she balances her two passions by farming fresh veggies at a small farm in the summer and creating content and marketing strategies for the painting industry in the winter. Emily is dedicated to clean data, smooth systems, and telling the stories of the painting industry.

When she isn’t working at a desk or in a field, she enjoys Colorado life with her two dogs and fiancé: hiking, snowboarding, tending her plants, and making pottery.

     
   
       

Subscribe to the Blog

           
       
                               
   
Please provide a short summary of why you are reaching out today.